Could Australia and New Zealand Become One Nation?

The Australia Letter is a weekly e-newsletter from our Australia bureau. Enroll to get it by e mail. This week’s problem is written by Natasha Frost, a reporter in Melbourne.

Turning into a republic, legalizing same-sex marriage, altering the Structure to determine an Aboriginal advisory physique: To make these adjustments to Australian life requires — or has required — no less than one nationwide vote.

But there’s a way more dramatic step that might — however virtually actually is not going to — happen with none polling in anyway: turning New Zealand into Australia’s seventh state.

The thought was lately mooted within the valedictory speech of Jamie Unusual, a departing Labour member of Parliament in New Zealand.

“Each time I go to Australia, I usually ponder the thought, ‘Will we ever grow to be one nation, Australia and New Zealand?’” he mentioned final week, including: “My private view — and it’s solely a private view — is that New Zealanders shouldn’t rule that out.”

(Among the many advantages Mr. Unusual listed was bringing the grocery store chain Aldi to New Zealand’s shores. Integrating the nation’s cricket groups, he mused, is perhaps a bridge too far.)

Chatting with the Australian information media this week, Barnaby Joyce, a former Australian deputy prime minister (and clandestine New Zealand citizen), acknowledged that such a change was unlikely to ever happen.

However, he mentioned, “we’d as nicely put it on the market,” including: “The protection coverage, financial coverage — we’d even win a rugby recreation!”

In Part 6 of the Australian Structure, drafted in 1900, New Zealand was listed as a possible Australian state. (Federation — when Australia’s six states united to type the Commonwealth of Australia — passed off on Jan. 1, 1901.)

Some years earlier, Australia had invited New Zealand to affix the federation. For quite a lot of causes, New Zealand declined.

John Corridor, a former premier of New Zealand, cited distance as a deciding issue throughout a convention on federation in Melbourne, Australia, in 1890.

“Nature has made 1,200 impediments to the inclusion of New Zealand in any such federation within the 1,200 miles of stormy ocean which lie between us and our brethren in Australia,” he mentioned, including: “Democratic authorities should be a authorities not just for the individuals, and by the individuals, however, whether it is to be environment friendly and provides content material, it should be in sight and inside listening to of the individuals.”

Australians, for his or her half, thought New Zealand may change its thoughts. Talking on the similar convention, William McMillan, an Australian politician, expressed such a hope.

“I consider that,” he mentioned, “when public opinion has sufficiently penetrated New Zealand, even New Zealand, separated from this continent by 1,200 miles of water, will come into the Federation of the Australasian Colonies.”

Geography was not the one consideration for New Zealand. Reporting earlier this yr for an article about adjustments to citizenship rights for New Zealanders residing in Australia, I spoke with Paul Hamer, a researcher at Victoria College of Wellington, in regards to the two nations’ historic relationship and their totally different approaches to race and migration.

“Australia wished New Zealand to federate in 1901. It wished to arrange a racially discriminatory state — ‘White Australia,’” he mentioned. “New Zealand was hesitant due to its Maori inhabitants,” and ultimately selected to go it alone.

These totally different approaches have reverberated throughout the many years. As my colleague Yan Zhuang wrote in final week’s e-newsletter, Australians can have their say about Aboriginal illustration in authorities in an Oct. 14 referendum. In New Zealand, a common election will happen on the identical day — and Indigenous voters will, as they’ve since 1867, have the chance to vote in seven electorates which might be reserved for Maori representatives.

There are many different causes such a merger doesn’t make sense, together with wildly totally different attitudes to nuclear energy, migration and the economic system.

So, all issues thought of, neither the All Blacks nor the Socceroos might want to fear in regards to the intricacies of tips on how to merge their rugby union and soccer groups with these of their rivals.

However that doesn’t imply that some, in each nations, gained’t proceed to ruminate on what may need been — and whether or not New Zealand ought to, as some economists counsel, merely import Australia’s tax code wholesale.

And within the meantime, Australia may take into account formally adopting a suggestion from the Australian comic Celeste Barber, who in 2020 known as on then-Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern to rename Australia “West New Zealand.”

Listed below are the week’s tales.

Are you having fun with our Australia bureau dispatches?
Inform us what you assume at NYTAustralia@nytimes.com.

Like this e mail?
Ahead it to your folks (they might use somewhat recent perspective, proper?) and allow them to know they’ll enroll right here.